From: Hassan Ibrahim

Sent: Thu Nov 20 13:13:37 2014

To: 'Jennifer Cline'

Cc: 'Dan Huff'; 'Heather Penni'; 'Joyce Stahly'

Subject: RE: Stowers, Heintz & Grange Estimate

Importance: Normal

Attachments: image001.png; 1613 Molalla Stowers Heintz Grange Rdwy Rehab Bid Tab.pdf;

 

Hello all,

Here is the bid tabulation from yesterday’s bid opening.

Regards,

--------------------

Hassan Ibrahim, P.E.

CURRAN-McLEOD, INC.

6655 SW Hampton St, Ste. 210

Portland, OR 97223

Tel: 503-684-3478

Fax: 503-624-8247

Cell: 503-807-2737

email: hai@curran-mcleod.com

From: Jennifer Cline [mailto:jcline@cityofmolalla.com]

Sent: Thursday, November 20, 2014 12:27 PM

To: hai@curran-mcleod.com

Cc: Dan Huff; Heather Penni

Subject: RE: Stowers, Heintz & Grange Estimate

Hi Hassan,

We don’t want to make any deletions to the contract at this time. The exchange funding we have available will cover the est. $459,608.85 plus room for contingencies if necessary. Will you provide the total Contract breakdown including, const. engineering and contingencies percentages?

Please hold off on sending out the “Notice of Intent to Award”. Dan is looking into any legal issues on our end if we award with approx.. $120,000 omission in the Engineer’s Estimate. I will let you know as soon as I hear how to proceed.

Regards,

Jennifer Cline, P.E.

City of Molalla

Public Works Director

O: 503.759.0218

F: 503.829.3676

image

From: Hassan Ibrahim [mailto:hai@curran-mcleod.com]

Sent: Thursday, November 20, 2014 9:21 AM

To: 'Jennifer Cline'

Cc: 'Heather Penni'; 'Dan Huff'

Subject: RE: Stowers, Heintz & Grange Estimate

Hi Jenn,

Low Bid Price $670,294.25

ODOT Exchange Fund ($459,608.85)

Water/Sewer Cost (SDC) ($114,660.00)

Balance $96,025.40 above budget

Most of the added cost is generated by adding storm drainage, removing and replacing existing sidewalks on Grange Ave, improvements at Molalla Communications, converting round catch basins to type G-2.

We can certainly delete the fabric on Grange and Heintz for a total of $24,750 if funding is tight.

As discussed, I intend to send the “Notice of Intent to Award” the contract today and start the 7 day protest period, please let us know if you want to do anything different.

Regards,

--------------------

Hassan Ibrahim, P.E.

CURRAN-McLEOD, INC.

6655 SW Hampton St, Ste. 210

Portland, OR 97223

Tel: 503-684-3478

Fax: 503-624-8247

Cell: 503-807-2737

email: hai@curran-mcleod.com

From: Jennifer Cline [mailto:jcline@cityofmolalla.com]

Sent: Thursday, November 20, 2014 8:51 AM

To: hai@curran-mcleod.com

Cc: Heather Penni; Dan Huff

Subject: RE: Stowers, Heintz & Grange Estimate

Hi Hassan,

This is outside our current available exchange funds. I know we receive additional funds next year, however I will need to run this passed Dan and Heather to discuss.

Thanks,

Jennifer Cline, P.E.

City of Molalla

Public Works Director

O: 503.759.0218

F: 503.829.3676

image

From: Hassan Ibrahim [mailto:hai@curran-mcleod.com]

Sent: Thursday, November 20, 2014 8:47 AM

To: 'Jennifer Cline'

Subject: Stowers, Heintz & Grange Estimate

Hi Jenn,

Just for your information, I compared the low bidder price to my cost estimate and they were comparable with no noticeable price spread between the two. So I crunched the numbers again on my estimate and found a mathematical error in section B under “Paving & Surfacing”. Attached is the estimate showing the corrected cost. $2,300 below the bid price.

Regards,

--------------------

Hassan Ibrahim, P.E.

CURRAN-McLEOD, INC.

6655 SW Hampton St, Ste. 210

Portland, OR 97223

Tel: 503-684-3478

Fax: 503-624-8247

Cell: 503-807-2737

email: hai@curran-mcleod.com