FW: Quote from Correct Equipment

From: Jennifer Cline

Sent: Fri Jun 19 15:21:19 2015

To: Phillip Bender

Subject: FW: Quote from Correct Equipment

Importance: Normal

Attachments: image002.gif; image003.png; image001.png;

This is from Marc opinion:

The yellow high-lighted below is what we have.

The blue high-lighted below is what we are switching to

Jennifer Cline, P.E.

City of Molalla

Public Works Director

O: 503.759.0218

F: 503.829.3676

"file:///C:

From: Jennifer Cline [mailto:jcline@cityofmolalla.com]

Sent: Friday, June 12, 2015 8:28 AM

To: Maisonville, Marc

Cc: Lee, Rob

Subject: RE: Quote from Correct Equipment

Hi Marc,

Thank you for your feedback and time on this matter.

Jennifer Cline, P.E.

City of Molalla

Public Works Director

O: 503.759.0218

F: 503.829.3676

From: Maisonville, Marc [mailto:mmaisonville@brwncald.com]

Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2015 9:03 PM

To: Jennifer Cline

Cc: Lee, Rob

Subject: RE: Quote from Correct Equipment

Hi Jennifer,

As mentioned, I wasn’t sure what type of instrument was being used to detect level. The quote from Correct Equipment is for an ultrasonic level transmitter (Pulsar Ultra 3) and transducer (dB10) with 30 ft cable. It’s not a submerged level transmitter that senses hydrostatic pressure and requires a breather tube in the cable for atmospheric reference. I was thinking your current sensor might be a submerged level transmitter because that’s what appears to be shown on the attached photo of the SCADA screen for the Transfer Pump Station. Maybe that was a previous incarnation…

In any case, a submerged level transmitter would not have a local display and I didn’t see a display in the field when I was there. The quoted Pulsar ultrasonic transmitter has a display/operator interface and is fascia mount meaning that it’s designed to be mounted into a cutout on a panel door. That would give you a local reading in the field independent of SCADA.

I do not have experience with Pulsar, but I talked to a colleague who has. He spoke favorably of them stating that they were easy to setup and that the transducers had powerful beams to help shoot through mist and foam.

As discussed, a third technology that is appropriate for this application is radar. As it happens I am getting quotes for radar transmitters for another project now and will let you know how that compares.

I look forward to hearing from Jason.

Thanks.

Marc Maisonville, PE

Brown and Caldwell

MMaisonville@brwncald.com

T 503.977.6626 | C