A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z AA AB AC AD AE AF AG AH
3   148                 17 44 70 10 8 6 27 49 14 30 16 70 42 22 32 23 17 31 16 15 18 0 0 0
5 AdditionalDocumentHyperlink ID FirstName LastName EmailAddress Organization State Comment AdditionalDocument CommentID FacilityNeighbor InOregon InUS OutsideUS SupportsRule OpposesRule WantsMoreComplianceTimeOrFlexibility ConsiderEconomicAffectOnGlassArtists OtherSourcesPolluteToo DontShutDownGlassIndustry ILikeGlass GlassArtist SupportsStatewide SupportsLowOrNoThreshold SupportsIncludingMoreMetalsInList SupportsHigherCaptureEfficiency SupportsRevisedBenchmarks SupportsIncludingAllGlassManufacturers SupportsHealthBased MorePublicInvolvement DetailedComment Notes DuplicateOfPrevious TestComment
69   194 Jessica Applegate applegatebrown@msn.com EPAC/Concerned citizen and neighbor of Bullseye OR Regard for the public health should be utmost in the decision making process and expedite emission controls installation. My family has been subjected to unfiltered emissions from Bullseye for decades. Knowing what we know now, it would seem the most prot 194 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
70   200 Barbara Peters barbaraannpeters@gmail.com Oregon As a resident of Portland who has suffered long-term exposure to toxic wood smoke and other air pollutants, I’m appalled that the art glass industry has been given a pass for so many years. No one should be involuntarily exposed to know 200 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
72   205 James Ofsink james@ofsink.today Oregon As a resident of SE Portland my chief concern is for the health of my neighbors, friends, family, and community members. Like many Oregonians I was disturbed to learn about the high levels of heavy metals and other toxins discovered recently in our air. T 205 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
74   212 Brittney Bieberich brittneymathews@gmail.com Oregon Loopholes that would allow for emissions of heavy metals from uncontrolled furnaces need to be closed. This needs to be applied state-wide to all glass manufacturers. Additionally, this needs to be applied to all heavy metals by September 1st.
The clea		 212 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
77   224 Barbara Peters barbaraannpeters@gmail.com Oregon As a resident of Portland who has suffered long-term exposure to toxic wood smoke and other air pollutants, I'm appalled that the art glass industry has been given a pass for so many years. No one should be involuntarily exposed to known carcinogens and a 224 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
82   242 Owen Kaufman owenkaufman1@gmail.com Oregon As a resident of Portland, I urge the DEQ to implement health-based regulations for ALL industrial facilities that emit toxins into our environment as soon as possible. 242 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
84   362 Karin Wagner portlandrolfer@gmail.com Rolfing Portland OR Thank you for working to make our air and our soil safer. I would appreciate the following changes:

1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions (not just the 6 Federally regulated ones).
2. Cover the whole state of Oregon
3. All glass factories,		 362 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE wants 99.9% capture rate
wants 'all glass factories', not just art glass		 FALSE FALSE
92   387 Michael Aiello redbarn.studio@live.com Aiello Fine Art OR I Live .4 miles from Bullseye for the past 9 years. Me my wife Amy and my 6 year old daughter each have High levels of Lead, Barium, Arsenic, Nickel and Cadmium. My daughter has high levels of Arsenic and Cadmium. We are not eating out of our garden this 387 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
94   389 Katharine Salzmann katharinesalzmann@gmail.com Eastside Portland Air Coalition (EPAC) Oregon I would like to request the following changes to the Temporary Rules for Art Glass Manufacturers:

1. Please include ALL heavy metals and potentially toxic substances used and emitted in the glassmaking process. Selenium, for example, is not included an		 389 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE revise benchmarks, revise rule to depend on new benchmarks
Apply to General Glass and Owens-Brockaway
wants 99.9% limit
video recording equipment for all public meetings		 FALSE FALSE
95   390 Karin Wagner portlandrolfer@gmail.com OR Thank you for working to make our air and our soil safer. I would appreciate the following changes:

1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions (not just the 6 Federally regulated ones).
2. Cover the whole state of Oregon
3. All glass factories,		 390 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture rate
all glass factories, not just art glass		 FALSE FALSE
96   395 Ruth Gundle ruth.gundle@icloud.com The Eighth Mountain Press OR 1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally regulated ones.
2. Make sure the health safety benchmarks are the most protective of human health they can be
3. Expand this rule to cover the whole state of Ore		 395 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE update health benchmarks
apply to all glass factories, not just art glass
99.9% capture rate		 FALSE FALSE
97   557 Julia Gaddis julia@jlgaddis.com   Please make permanent the "Temporary Rules for Art Glass."

For our citizens and our children and future, please:
Ask the DEQ to:

1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally regulated ones.
2. M		 557 FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture rate
revise health benchmarks
apply to all glass factories, not just art glass		 FALSE FALSE
99   566 Robert Thompson salalscape@yahoo.com   Dear DEQ,

When considering the glass rules please:

1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally regulated ones.
2. Make sure the health safety benchmarks are the most protective of human health they can b		 566 FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture
update health benchmarks		 FALSE FALSE
103   608 Cindy Young rocknrollschool@msn.com Oregon [submitted by email]
As a long term resident living less than a half mile from Bullseye and a member of EPAC I have followed the rule making process and these are my concerns.
Concerns that were also shared by all participants of the fiscal committee.
The		 608 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE suggests 500 lb threshold instead of 10 tons FALSE FALSE
104 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/fe330805-5c36-48a6-a17a-6466414f641e?filename=permanent+rule+public+comments+FINAL.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf# 612 Al Hooton al@glassalchemy.com Glass Alchemy Oregon Please see attached comments document. https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/fe330805-5c36-48a6-a17a-6466414f641e?filename=permanent+rule+public+comments+FINAL.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf 612 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE supports lower threshold calculated based on modeling and ambient benchmarks
and grain loading standard at 0.005 gr/dscf		 FALSE FALSE
105 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/159a9290-9d5b-4704-b6d0-8fdd3e74314e?filename=E%3A%5CJoe%27s+Documents%5CAir+Toxics+Rulemaking+2016%5Ctemp+to+permanent%5C4%29+public+comments%5Cerror+reports%5Ccomments+that+need+to+be+manually+included%5CK+ 616 K Hamill voiceofathena@yahoo.com Oregon [submitted by email, see attachment]

K. Hamill
voiceofathena@yahoo.com
Oregon

As a lifelong Portlander, I have a stake in the quality of our air. I also highly value art and all the positives the local glass community has brought to our city. That puts 		https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/159a9290-9d5b-4704-b6d0-8fdd3e74314e?filename=E%3A%5CJoe%27s+Documents%5CAir+Toxics+Rulemaking+2016%5Ctemp+to+permanent%5C4%29+public+comments%5Cerror+reports%5Ccomments+that+need+to+be+manually+included%5CK+H 616 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE regulate differently for making from raw materials vs those who re-melt. Any size manufacturer that is using raw materials should be regulated. FALSE FALSE
106   1068 Sage Cohen sage@sagecohen.com Sage Communications OR I would like you to: 1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally regulated ones.
2. Make sure the health safety benchmarks are the most protective of human health they can be
3. Expand this rule to cover t		 1068 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% control efficiency
apply to all glass manufacturers
revise health benchmarks		 FALSE FALSE
108   1082 Rob Nosse rep.robnosse@state.or.us State Representative Oregon As a representative and resident of Southeast Portland, I am deeply concerned about the environmental and human health impacts of uncontrolled metal emissions.  If we truly care about the health of all Oregonians, I encourage the DEQ and EQC t 1082 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
111   1097 Cynthia Eckersley cynthia.eckersley@gmail.com EPAC Oregon Please consider doing the following when rewriting the rules: 1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally regulated ones.
2. Make sure the health safety benchmarks are the most protective of human health		 1097 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture
include all glass factories
revise health benchmarks		 FALSE FALSE
114   1348 Robert Thompson salalscape@yahoo.com   Dear DEQ,
Thank you for implementing temporary rules to protect my family from toxic glass work pollution. As you consider making permanent rules I ask that you:

1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally		 1348 FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture rate
apply to all glass factories, not just art glass		 FALSE FALSE
115   1349 Surah Hirsch drshirsch@aol.com   PLEASE:


1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally regulated ones.
2. Make sure the health safety benchmarks are the most protective of human health they can be
3. Expand this rule to cover the whole st		 1349 FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture rate
apply to all glass factories, not just art glass		 FALSE FALSE
117   1351 Kerry Ryan kerrysilvaryan@gmail.com Oregon I suport the efforts of my neighbors' requests for the permanent glass rules. In particular, please... Close loopholes that would allow for emissions of heavy metals from uncontrolled furnaces, apply rules state-wide; apply to all glass manufacturers, not 1351 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE ensure public notice and comment instead of locking the public out of DEQ decisions
health-based standards		 FALSE FALSE
118   1366 Robert Clapp Profigliano1@yahoo.com Citizen OR 1. All heavy metals can be hazardous/poisonous/neurotoxic/teratogenic, etc. They should all be regulated, not just the six proposed.

2. Rule should cover all of Oregon, not just PDX.

3. The benchmarks should be the safest/highest known to science--an		 1366 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE benchmarks should be the most conservative
99.9% capture rate
all glass manufacturers, not just art glass		 FALSE FALSE
119 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/7baa2f42-5c8e-453b-a502-93ceacfa9cb0?filename=GlassRulesComment.txt&content_type=text%2Fplain# 1367 K Hamill voiceofathena@yahoo.com Oregon   https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/7baa2f42-5c8e-453b-a502-93ceacfa9cb0?filename=GlassRulesComment.txt&content_type=text%2Fplain 1367 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE include all sources of metal emissions
some of comment is a duplicate of their previous entry.		 FALSE FALSE
121   1611 Amanda Jarman amanda@amandajarman.net Eastside Portland Air Coalition Oregon Please pass the strongest rules you can to protect air quality.

These rules should include all glass art manufacturers by lowering the production threshold to 1 pound of glass produced per year.

These rules should also apply statewide. Nobody, regardl		 1611 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
127   1875 Sarah Wilkinson Snkonk@pdx.edu Parents of SE Portland Oregon. MY DAUGHTER'S HEALTH!!! THE HEALTH OF FUTURE GENERATIONS IN PORTLAND.

- Close loopholes that would allow for emissions of heavy metals from uncontrolled furnaces
- Apply to all heavy metals by September 1st.
- Both filterable and condensable hazardous e		 1875 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE control filterable and condensable at 99.9%
apply to all glass manufacturers
more public notice and comment
health-based standards		 FALSE FALSE
130   1946 Jody Bleyle bleyle@gmail.com Eastside Portland Air Coalition OR Please create standards that are protective of human health. Health-based standards. Not tech-based or risk-based, but health-based.

Please close all loopholes that allow emissions of ALL heavy metals and HAPS from uncontrolled furnaces.

Please apply 		1946 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE wants health-based standards
all glass manufacturers not just CAGM		 FALSE FALSE
131 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/64476b17-ebe2-433b-9b67-d570962f0e49?filename=7-29-16+Final+Group+Comments+on+CAGM+Rule.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf# 1947 Chris Winter chris@crag.org Crag Law Cener Oregon I have attached a set of group comments from fifteen social justice and environmental organizations. Thank you. https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/64476b17-ebe2-433b-9b67-d570962f0e49?filename=7-29-16+Final+Group+Comments+on+CAGM+Rule.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf 1947 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE wants health-based not technology based
500 lb/year threshold not 10 tpy
legal requirement to consider effect on EJ communities
rule should only apply to furnaces to which NESHAP 6S does not apply
no emissions before DEQ permit issued
public participation		 FALSE FALSE
133   1954 robin denburg denburg@riseup.net Richmond community Oregon I have high levels of heavy metals in my yard and air since I am 6 blocks from Bullseye glass. They have repeatedly shown they are not a good actor and I need DEQ's involvement to help protect my community's air and soil.

I would request you:
- Close lo		 1954 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE health-based standards
99.9% capture
filterable and condensable		 FALSE FALSE
136 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/fe46aa36-98c1-4341-959f-836f145851ec?filename=E%3A%5CJoe%27s+Documents%5CAir+Toxics+Rulemaking+2016%5Ctemp+to+permanent%5C4%29+public+comments%5Cerror+reports%5Ccomments+that+need+to+be+manually+included%5C16 1968 Abe Fleishman abef@northstarglass.com Northstar Glassworks, Inc. Oregon see attachment [submitted by email] https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/fe46aa36-98c1-4341-959f-836f145851ec?filename=E%3A%5CJoe%27s+Documents%5CAir+Toxics+Rulemaking+2016%5Ctemp+to+permanent%5C4%29+public+comments%5Cerror+reports%5Ccomments+that+need+to+be+manually+included%5C160 1968 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE suggests baghouse outlet grain loading limit of 0.01 gr/dscf or 0.001 gr/dscf as a replacement for 99% standard
500 lbs/year threshold instead of 10 tpy
add cadmium to list of metals (currently Cr6) that tier 1s can't use in uncontrolled furnace
keep Tier		 FALSE FALSE
137 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/6a8588ac-d7f2-45f1-8ac6-3c001d4e2d89?filename=Jame%27s+DEQ+Commentary0001.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf# 1969 James Knox jamesk@northstarglass.com Northstar Glassworks, inc. Orgeon   https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/6a8588ac-d7f2-45f1-8ac6-3c001d4e2d89?filename=Jame%27s+DEQ+Commentary0001.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf 1969 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE supports change from 99% control efficiency to grain loading FALSE FALSE
138   1972 Elizabeth LeDoux 26ledoux@gmail.com Oregon - Close loopholes that would allow for emissions of heavy metals from uncontrolled furnaces
- Apply to all heavy metals by September 1st.
- Both filterable and condensable hazardous emissions must be controlled at 99.9% capture
- Apply state-wide
- Apply 		1972 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE filterable and condensable 99.9% FALSE FALSE
139   1973 Jennifer Jones Jennifer@eastsideportlandair.org Eastside Portland air coalition Oregon I hope the DEQ is panicking as much as neighbors over the recent realization that even filtered emissions are not trapping all the cr6 pouring into the SE neighborhood surrounding bullseye glass.

DEQ MUST close the loopholes that allow for emissions of 		1973 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE health-based standards FALSE FALSE
141   1977 Laura Raymond karlaura@comcast.net Oregon My family and I have lived less than a mile from Bullseye Glass for the past 10 years and our daughter and niece have spent 11 (combined) years attending Winterhaven and Cleveland, with a (combined) 6 years left at Cleveland) – every da 1977 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE filterable and condensable 99.9%
all HAPs		 FALSE FALSE
142   1982 Jen Davis Weallneedbees@gmail.com Bee Friendly Portland OR - Close loopholes that would allow for emissions of heavy metals from uncontrolled furnaces
- Apply to all heavy metals by September 1st.
- Both filterable and condensable hazardous emissions must be controlled at 99.9% capture
- Apply state-wide
- Apply 		1982 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE filterable and condensable FALSE FALSE
146   1990 Rob Nosse rep.robnosse@state.or.us OR As a representative and resident of Southeast Portland, I am deeply concerned about the environmental and human health impacts of uncontrolled metal emissions.  If we truly care about the health of all Oregonians, I encourage the DEQ and EQC t 1990 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE   FALSE FALSE
147 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/90cc97da-0eb1-4fc1-81c3-2ee74239be42?filename=Comments+on+Manufacturer+RulesMultcoFinal.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf# 1996 Joanne Fuller joanne.fuller@multco.us Multnomah County Health Dept Oregon see attached https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/90cc97da-0eb1-4fc1-81c3-2ee74239be42?filename=Comments+on+Manufacturer+RulesMultcoFinal.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf 1996 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE don't allow Cr use in uncontrolled furnaces
reduce 10 tpy threshold
do fuel-fired furnaces really emit more than electrically fired (enough to merit use in criteria between Tier 1 / Tier 2)?
Use 0.35 ng/m3 as 24-hr limit for Cr6 (from Ontario)		 FALSE FALSE
148 #https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/f3993279-bb59-4051-b510-99df07d70ae7?filename=LTR+to+EQC+07292016.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf# 1999 Cecilia Youngs cyoungs@yoakum.com Attorney at Law Washington My comment attached. https://data.oregon.gov/views/54i7-gnrh/files/f3993279-bb59-4051-b510-99df07d70ae7?filename=LTR+to+EQC+07292016.pdf&content_type=application%2Fpdf 1999 FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE "thermal oxidizers"
no metals in uncontrolled furnaces
no chromium in any form should be allowed
require regular monitoring of emissions
revise ambient benchmarks		 FALSE FALSE
149   2006 Ted Whitney tr_whitney@yahoo.com Oregon I am a glass and multimedia artist residing in Portland, Oregon. I have used glass manufactured by Bullseye and Uroboros for many years. I have the following comments on the proposed rules for colored art glass manufacturers.
1) The DEQ should close an		 2006 FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE 99.9% control efficiency
'close loopholes that allow emissions from uncontrolled furnaces'
include condensable particulate matter
consider fugitive emissions
etc		 FALSE FALSE
150 #\\deqhq1\rule_development\Currrent Plan\AQ-Art Glass 2016 - Westersund\5-Public comment and testimony\comment attachments\CRAG law center letter submitted by Katharine Salzmann at 7-19-2016 hearing.pdf# 2007 Katharine Salzmann   EPAC Oregon submitted in hard copy at 7/19/2016 public hearing \\deqhq1\rule_development\Currrent Plan\AQ-Art Glass 2016 - Westersund\5-Public comment and testimony\comment attachments\CRAG law center letter submitted by Katharine Salzmann at 7-19-2016 hearing.pdf 2007 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE submitted copy of CRAG Law Center's comments during the temporary rule rulemaking. Points Katharine emphasized:
the rule is not health-based,
should not allow emissions from any uncontrolled furnaces, and
is too narrow (should apply statewide and to al		 FALSE FALSE
152   2358 Cynthia Eckersley cynthia.eckersley@gmail.com EPAC Oregon Hello,
I tried to submit my comments via you website, with out any luck. I would like to submit the following as essential to the rules being rewritten by DEQ. I am part of the EPAC (East Portland Air Coalition) and live within 1/2 mile of Bullseye Glass		 2358 TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture efficiency
all glass factories, not just CAGM
update health benchmarks		 FALSE FALSE
153   2359 Sage Cohen sage@sagecohen.com   Hello. Your website comments function is not working.

I would like to request that you:

1. Include ALL heavy metals and hazardous emissions for regulation, not just the 6 Federally regulated ones.
2. Make sure the health safety benchmarks are the mos		 2359 FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE FALSE TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE 99.9% capture efficiency
all glass factories, not just CAGM
update health benchmarks		 FALSE FALSE

raw

  A B C D E
1       148 total
3 Category   Number    
4 FacilityNeighbor Facility Neighbor 17 11%  
5 InOregon Elsewhere in Oregon 44 30%  
6 InUS Elsewhere in US 70 47%  
7 OutsideUS Outside US 10 7%  
8   Did not say 7 5%  
10 ILikeGlass I Like Glass 16    
11 GlassArtist Glass Artist 70    
13 SupportsRule Supports rule 8    
14 OpposesRule Opposes rule 6    
15 WantsMoreComplianceTimeOrFlexibility Wants more compliance time or flexibility 27    
16 ConsiderEconomicAffectOnGlassArtists Consider economic effect on glass artists 49    
17 OtherSourcesPolluteToo Other sources pollute too 14    
18 DontShutDownGlassIndustry Don’t shut down glass industry 30    
19 SupportsStatewide Supports applying rule statewide 42    
20 SupportsLowOrNoThreshold Supports lowering 10 tpy threshold 22    
21 SupportsIncludingMoreMetalsInList Supports including more metals in list 32    
22 SupportsHigherCaptureEfficiency Supports higher capture efficiency (99.9%) 23    
23 SupportsRevisedBenchmarks Supports revised health benchmarks 17    
24 SupportsIncludingAllGlassManufacturers Supports including all glass manufacturers 31    
25 SupportsHealthBased Wants this rule to be "health-based" 16    
26 MorePublicInvolvement Wants more public involvement 15    
27 DetailedComment Detailed comment 18    
28 Notes   0    
29 DuplicateOfPrevious   0    
30 TestComment   0    

stats

  A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O
1
                           
2                              
3                              
4                              
5                              
6                              
7                              
8                              
9                              
10                              
11                              
12                              
13                              
14                              
15                              
16                              
17                              
18                              
19                              
20                              
21                              
22                              
23                              
24                              
25                              
26                              
27                              
28                              
29                              
30                              
31                              
32                              
33                              

Types

  A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O
1
                           
2                              
3                              
4                              
5                              
6                              
7                              
8                              
9                              
10                              
11                              
12                              
13                              
14                              
15                              
16                              
17                              
18                              
19                              
20                              
21                              
22                              
23                              
24                              
25                              
26                              
27                              
28                              
29                              
30                              
31                              
32                              
33                              

Geography