Comparison of New Area Requirements

Comparison of Proposed Requirements for New Areas

Source Emissions after the PSEL incr.	Proposed Requirements for Attainment Areas	Proposed Requirements for Sustainment Areas	Proposed Requirements for Nonattainment Areas Somewhere explain change to FM classification
250 tons per year or 100 tons per year or for specified sources	Source is classified as Federal Major Preconstruction monitoring *** BACT * AQ analysis • NAAQS and PSD Increments Additional impacts analysis * AQRV analysis	Source is classified as Federal Major Preconstruction monitoring (required) BACT * AQ analysis • NAAQS and PSD Increments Offsets • 1.1:1 for ozone • 1.0:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources Additional impacts analysis * AQRV analysis	Source is classified as Federal Major LAER * Offsets • 1.1:1 for ozone • 1.2:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources NAQB • Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS AQRV analysis Alternative sites analysis * Certify compliance for all sources *
100 tons per year to 249 tons per year for unspecified sources	Source is classified as Major AQ analysis • NAAQS and PSD Increments	Source is classified as Federal Major Preconstruction monitoring (required) BACT * AQ analysis • NAAQS and PSD Increments Offsets • 1.1:1 for ozone • 1.0:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources Additional impacts analysis * AQRV analysis	Source is classified as Federal Major LAER * Offsets • 1.1:1 for ozone • 1.2:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources NAQB • Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS AQRV analysis Alternative sites analysis * Certify compliance for all sources *
SER to 99 tons per year	AQ analysis • NAAQS and PSD Increments		Source is classified as Minor BACT * Offsets • 1.1:1 for ozone • 1.0:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources NAQB • Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS
Less than SER	NC rules or ACDP	NC rules or ACDP, no change	NC rules or ACDP, no change

* If a Major Modification is involved

** Offset ratio varies for certain areas such as Medford PM10, etc.

Source Emissions after the PSEL incr.
Proposed Requirements for Nonattainment Areas

Somewhere explain change to FM classification
Proposed Requirements for Reattainment Areas
Proposed Requirements for Maintenance Areas
100 tons per year or more
Source is classified as Federal Major

LAER *

Offsets

• 1.1:1 for ozone

• 1.2:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources

NAQB

• Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS

AQRV analysis

Alternative sites analysis *

Certify compliance for all sources *

Source is classified as Federal Major

Preconstruction Monitoring ***

BACT *

AQ analysis

• NAAQS and PSD Increments

Maintenance area AQ protection

• Offsets

◦ 1.1:1 for ozone

◦ 1.0:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources ** and NAQB

▪ Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS

Or

• Growth allowance

Or

• Model below maintenance area limits

Additional impacts analysis

AQRV analysis

SER to 99 tons per year
Source is classified as Minor

BACT *

Offsets

• 1.1:1 for ozone

• 1.0:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources

NAQB

• Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS

Source is classified as Minor

-

BACT *

AQ analysis

• NAAQS and PSD Increments

Maintenance area AQ protection

• Offsets

◦ 1.1:1 for ozone

◦ 1.0:1 for other pollutants ** and NAQB

▪ Reduce impacts at majority of receptors; and

▪ Impacts less than SIL at all receptors

Or

• Growth allowance

Or

• Model below maintenance area limits

Less than SER
NC rules or ACDP, no change

NC rules or ACDP, no change

Source Emissions after the PSEL incr.	Proposed Requirements for Nonattainment Areas Somewhere explain change to FM classification	Proposed Requirements for Reattainment Areas	Proposed Requirements for Maintenance Areas
100 tons per year or more	Source is classified as Federal* Major* LAER * Offsets • 1.1:1 for ozone • 1.2:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources NAQB • Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS AQRV analysis Alternative sites analysis * Certify compliance for all sources *		Source is classified as Federal* Major* Preconstruction Monitoring *** BACT * AQ analysis • NAAQS and PSD Increments Maintenance area AQ protection • Offsets ◦ 1.1:1 for ozone ◦ 1.0:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources and NAQB ▪ Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS** Or • Growth allowance Or • Model below maintenance area limits Additional impacts analysis AQRV analysis
SER to 99 tons per year	Source is classified as Minor BACT * Offsets • 1.1:1 for ozone • 1.0:1 for other pollutants, with provision to reduce the ratio if offsets are obtained from priority sources NAQB • Source plus competing sources since area was designated less than 10% of the NAAQS		Source is classified as Minor - BACT * AQ analysis • NAAQS and PSD Increments Maintenance area AQ protection • Offsets ◦ 1.1:1 for ozone ◦ 1.0:1 for other pollutants ** and NAQB ▪ Reduce impacts at majority of receptors; and ▪ Impacts less than SIL at all receptors Or • Growth allowance Or • Model below maintenance area limits
Less than SER	NC rules or ACDP, no change		NC rules or ACDP, no change