Source

Emissions Unit

Source Test Results

Potential Control Equipmenti

Feedback from sources

DEQ Comment

Pre-1970 Boilers > 0.10 gr/dscf

Boise Cascade (Pilot Rock)

 

30-0016

Early 1940s Babcock & Wilcox Dutch-oven boilers, 2 @ 20,000 lb steam/hr, 1 @ 8,000 lb steam/hr;

Backup to NG fired boiler.

Boiler 1: 0.08-0.17 and 0.4% (6 tests);

 

Boiler 3: 0.08-0.19 and 0-1% (8 tests); Boiler 4: 0.06-0.10 (4 tests)

Need uniform, dry fuel; steady load. 

Company indicated concern about control device which requires an air flow system that is incompatible with natural draft stacks. Because boilers are backup, company could decide to stop using the boilers rather than control.

Different from other Dutch oven boilers with multiclones?

Columbia Forest Products

 

18-0014

1944 C& E Dutch oven BLR-S w/multiclone, 35,000 lb steam/hr

 

1939 EF Huffman Dutch oven BLR-N at 12,500 lb steam/hr)

BLR-S: 0.08 – 0.19 (11 tests); 5 – 17% (10 tests);

BLR-N: 0.09 – 0.14 (3 tests); 1 – 5% (3 tests)

Need controls

  

Frank Lumber

 

22-2525

1969 Wyatt & Kipper spreader stoker boiler, 30,000 lb/hr steam, w/multiclone

’89 - 0.19

’97- 0.178

‘04 -0.137

’09 - 0.137

 

Need controls

Already tuned well

 

 

Interfor Pacific

 

18-0005

1939 Wickes Dutch oven boilers (2), 50,000 lb/hr ea, multiclones, economizer

Common stack – can comply with 0.1 during normal operations. Boiler 1 – 6% and 0.11; Boiler 2 – 2% and 0.15

Looking at ESP

Already does a lot of maintenance and tuning

Could run boiler harder, thinking of boiler changes to comply with boiler MACT, don’t want to be a synthetic minor

Swanson Group Roseburg

 

10-0030

1968 Kipper boilers, pin hole grate, mechanical stoker, 31,800 lb steam/hr w/multiclone

0.17 at 26,800 #/hr steam

Looking for used ESP

 

> 26,800 then NG boiler starts up.

Post-1970 Boilers > 0.10 gr/dscf

Collins (Fremont Sawmill)

 

19-0002

 

’75 Wickes Dutch oven, 18,000 lb/yr, multiclone;

 

’89 Trane-Murray Dutch oven, 24,000 lb/hr multiclone

Boiler 1: 0.13

 

Boiler 2: 0.09

Needs controls

Already does a lot of maintenance, cannot meet 0.10 consistently

0.1 gr/dscf permit limit

Prineville Sawmill

07-0021

HFB

0.16 gr/dscf

  

0.1 gr/dscf permit limit,

not operating

Umpqua Lumber

10-0027

1975 Wellons boiler w/multiclone, 20,000 lb/hr

0.12 gr/dscf

  

0.1 gr/dscf permit limit

Pre-1970 Boilers < 0.10 gr/dscf

Roseburg Forest Product facilities Riddle

 

10-0078

1968 Wyatt-Kipper spreader-stoker HFB, 110,000 lb steam/hr

 

 

1978 Kipper spreader-stoker HFB, 70,000 lb/hr,

0.017 lb/M lb steam

 

 

 

 

0.184 lb/M lb steam (BACT)

Western Pacific multiclone w/110 cyclones; 2006 dry ESP

 

Zurn multiclone (12 cyclones) with Ducon Spray tower wet scrubber

in anticipation of the original Boiler MACT

0.2, 20%

 

 

 

 

 

0.1; 20%

Roseburg Forest Product facilities Coquille

 

06-0010

1958 Garrett & Schafer bentwood tube spreader-stoker HFB, 80,000 lb steam/hr;

0.038 lb/M lb steam

2006 dry ESPs added after the existing multiclone controls

in anticipation of the original Boiler MACT

0.2, 20%

Swanson Group Glendale

10-0045

1951 Babcock & Wilcox Dutch oven HFB, 125 MMBtu/hr

0.025 lb/M lbs steam at 58,000 lb/hr

Multiclone and dry ESP

 

0.2

Asphalt Plants

Harney Rock and Paving

13-0010

Asphalt plant

19% and 0.22 (‘99)

Wet scrubber

~$32,000

  

Humbert Asphalt

37-0112

Asphalt plant

0.11 - 7/03

   

Rogers Asphalt Paving

31-0001

Asphalt plant

0.11

Wet scrubber

~$32,000

  

Valley Paving

23-0031

Asphalt plant

0.231- 5/13

  

Violation of 0.1 gr/dscf