From: CleanFuelsAug2012

Sent: Tue Aug 07 14:57:58 2012

To: 'atul@whole-energy.com'; 'Michael Vevera'

Cc: CleanFuelsAug2012; WIND Cory Ann

Subject: RE: Comments Regarding Clean Fuels Standard

Importance: Normal

Thank you for your comments.

Can you provide me with the calculations for the pathways requested below? Either in OR-GREET or an equivalent lifecycle analysis model.

Cory-Ann Wind

Air Quality Planner

wind.cory@deq.state.or.us

503-229-5388

From: Atul Deshmane [mailto:atul@whole-energy.com]

Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2012 2:51 PM

To: CleanFuelsAug2012

Cc: WIND Cory Ann; 'Michael Vevera'

Subject: Comments Regarding Clean Fuels Standard

Hello,

Whole Energy is a producer and distributor of renewable fuels in BC, WA, OR, and CA. We currently provide biodiesel and renewable natural gas. We are interested in providing renewable electricity and propane as a transportation fuel. We would like to see the inclusion of the following in the Clean Fuels Standard:

1. 1. An allowance of a pathway for 100% renewable natural gas that is placed into a pipeline and then conveyed to a specific transportation end-user
2. 2. An allowance of a pathway for 100% renewable electricity that is placed into an electrical grid and then conveyed to a specific transportation end-user
3. 3. An allowance of a pathway for 100% renewable LPG-substitute such as di-methyl ether to be used as a low carbon transportation fuel

We are interested in participating in the adoption of this program. We also suggest that a reporting tool somewhat like what is available under the CA LCFS Reporting Tool be developed and tested long before any users are expected to utilize it.

Regards, Atul

Atul Deshmane

Whole Energy

206.446.1333

*** This message may contain information that is privileged and confidential. If you think you have received this communication in error, notify Whole Energy at info@whole-energy.com or by telephone at (206) 446-1333 ***